LOUISVILLE CAN’T FORCE CHRISTIAN PHOTOGRAPHER TO SHOOT SAME-SEX WEDDINGS

Legal

LOUISVILLE CAN’T FORCE CHRISTIAN PHOTOGRAPHER TO SHOOT SAME-SEX WEDDIN…

MDHan 0 8,591 2022.09.01 00:00
2,510 https://www.christianpost.com/news/city-cant-force-christian-photograp…
Chelsey Nelson is a wedding photographer and blogger in Louisville, Kentucky. | Courtesy of Chelsey Nelson 

CP U.S. | THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 01, 2022


Louisville can’t force Christian photographer to shoot same-sex weddings, federal court rules

By Michael Gryboski, Mainline Church Editor 

Kentucky's largest city cannot punish a professional Christian photographer for refusing on religious grounds to photograph same-sex wedding ceremonies, a federal court has ruled.

U.S. District Judge Benjamin Beaton of the Western District of Kentucky ruled Tuesday that Louisville could not enforce its LGBT nondiscrimination ordinance against photographer Chelsey Nelson, who is "motivated by her faith to celebrate marriage as the union of only opposite-sex couples."           

Beaton, an appointee of former President Donald Trump, granted a summary injunction and argued the city's ordinance preventing discrimination based on sexual orientation violated Nelson's freedom of speech rights.

He stated that while the city "may require restaurants and hotels and stores to provide services regardless of the proprietors' views or their customers' legal status, the government may not force singers or writers or photographers to articulate messages they don't support."

"The freedom of speech — especially for minority views — is a core premise of our democratic republic," ruled Beaton. "As prevailing sentiments and politics have changed over the years, robust constitutional protection for differing views has remained fixed.

"The judge concluded that the First Amendment is "necessary to protect the discourse of same-sex couples and their supporters."

"Because the U.S. Constitution supersedes Louisville's Fairness Ordinance as a matter of law, this Court enjoins the City from either compelling or suppressing Nelson's photography and writing," he continued.

Jonathan Scruggs of Alliance Defending Freedom, who argued Nelson's case on Aug. 7, said in a statement Wednesday he believes "photographers and writers like Chelsey should be free to peacefully live and work according to their faith without fear of unjust punishment by the government."

"The court was right to halt enforcement of Louisville's law against Chelsey while her case moves forward. She serves everyone," said Scruggs.

Comments

로그인한 회원만 댓글 등록이 가능합니다.
번호 제목 글쓴이 날짜 조회
71 Supreme Court upholds laws banning trans athletes from women… IdealAdventure 07.01 1183
70 PRESIDENTIAL ACTIONS: DEFENDING WOMEN FROM GENDER IDEOLOGY E… IdealAdventure 05.30 1386
69 Thune to take MAJOR action on SAVE America Act: Report IdealAdventure 03.12 2068
68 UK Supreme Court rules on definition of a woman IdealAdventure 2025.09.15 3309
67 UPenn to ban trans athletes from women's sports, revoke Lia … IdealAdventure 2025.07.02 3561
66 Parents can opt kids out of LGBTQ book lessons, Supreme Cour… IdealAdventure 2025.06.27 3776
65 UK Supreme Court issues landmark ruling on legal definition … IdealAdventure 2025.04.17 4616
64 Establishment of The White House Faith Office IdealAdventure 2025.02.12 5516
63 When is gender determined? IdealAdventure 2024.10.29 5229
62 Far Left Berkeley Law Professor Melts Down When Sen. Hawley … IdealAdventure 2024.09.18 5940
61 West Virginia Student Helps Pass Bill to Teach Intelligent D… IdealAdventure 2024.06.11 6542
60 Alabama Gov. Kay Ivey signs to ban DEI bill into law IdealAdventure 2024.03.21 7040
59 Tennessee, Public officials to refuse to perform same-sex ma… IdealAdventure 2024.03.01 6619
58 Is There A Difference Between Women And Men? IdealAdventure 2024.02.29 6668
57 Ohio House Overrides Veto on Bill Banning Trans Interventio… IdealAdventure 2024.01.20 7272
Category
Medical
Denominational
Theological
Social
Historical
Legal
+ Posts
+ Comments
Facebook Twitter GooglePlus KakaoStory NaverBand